SEED GAME#19613 BGG all-time

Among Thieves(2019)

★ 5.9 BGG3–8 players30 minWeight 1.40
Prisoner's DilemmaSimultaneous Action SelectionTake That

Games like Among Thieves

Looking for games like Among Thieves? It's quick to teach and quick to play, easy to get to the table on any night. This page rounds up 12 of the closest alternatives, scored on mechanical overlap with the original (45%), complexity match (35%), and player-count fit (20%), then weighted by BoardGameGeek community ratings so every pick is one players genuinely rate. The strongest matches come first; the further down you go, the more a game trades exact overlap for a fresh take on the same core appeal.

How ISO scores this list:Mechanic overlap 45%·Complexity proximity 35%·Player-count fit 20%·BGG quality multiplier applied

12 recommendations · scored by ISO

Pirate Den(2015)

★ 6.43–5 playersWeight 1.2
ISO Match
70/100

Shares Simultaneous Action Selection + 1 more

Hand ManagementSimultaneous Action SelectionTake That

Dead Last(2016)

★ 6.26–12 playersWeight 1.2
ISO Match
69/100

Shares Prisoner's Dilemma + 2 more

Player EliminationPrisoner's DilemmaSimultaneous Action Selection

Hunters of the Lost Creatures(2023)

★ 6.72–5 playersWeight 1.1
ISO Match
68/100

Shares Simultaneous Action Selection + 1 more

Set CollectionSimultaneous Action SelectionTake That

XYbrid(2017)

★ 6.52–4 players15 minWeight 1.3
ISO Match
67/100

Shares Simultaneous Action Selection + 1 more

Open DraftingSimultaneous Action SelectionTake That

Whirling Witchcraft(2021)

★ 7.22–5 playersWeight 1.8
ISO Match
67/100

Shares Simultaneous Action Selection + 1 more

Simultaneous Action SelectionTake ThatVariable Player Powers

Bezzerwizzer Timeline(2021)

★ 6.72–99 players20 minWeight 1.0
ISO Match
67/100

Shares Simultaneous Action Selection + 1 more

Simultaneous Action SelectionTake That

Supernatural Socks(2018)

★ 6.22–4 players15 minWeight 1.5
ISO Match
66/100

Shares Simultaneous Action Selection + 1 more

Set CollectionSimultaneous Action SelectionTake That

El Dorado Canyon(2015)

★ 8.74–6 players30 minWeight 1.8
ISO Match
66/100

Shares Simultaneous Action Selection + 1 more

Push Your LuckSimultaneous Action SelectionTake That

Eminent Domain: Battlecruisers(2016)

★ 6.33–5 playersWeight 1.9
ISO Match
66/100

Shares Simultaneous Action Selection + 1 more

Player EliminationSimultaneous Action SelectionTake That

IncrediBrawl(2014)

★ 5.72–4 players30 minWeight 1.6
ISO Match
66/100

Shares Simultaneous Action Selection + 1 more

Rock-Paper-ScissorsSimultaneous Action SelectionTake That

Dungeons & Dragons: Rock Paper Wizard(2016)

★ 6.53–6 playersWeight 1.3
ISO Match
66/100

Shares Simultaneous Action Selection + 1 more

Simultaneous Action SelectionTake That

Dragons & Chickens(2016)

★ 6.22–5 players15 minWeight 1.3
ISO Match
65/100

Shares Simultaneous Action Selection + 1 more

Pattern RecognitionSimultaneous Action SelectionTake That

As an Amazon Associate, ISO earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability vary; ISO never displays prices. Affiliate links are marked rel="sponsored" per FTC guidelines.

IS

Get picks tuned to your shelf

This list is built from community data. Sign in to ISO and log what you own — your personal feed factors in your complexity preferences, play history, and the games already on your shelf.

Get personalized recommendations →

Free · no credit card · 2-minute setup

More recommendation lists